New York Pizza Co Menu

Potato Wedges

Thick-cut, golden brown, and perfectly seasoned. Crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside — our potato wedges are the ultimate comfort side, served hot and ready for dipping. Served with ketchup.

Garlic Knots

Golden, buttery knots tossed in garlic and herbs. Served with marinara.

Classic Buffalo Wings

The original wing king. Tangy, zesty, and just the right amount of heat to keep you coming back for more — messy fingers required.

Garlic Parmesan Wings

Buttery garlic goodness meets a shower of Parmesan cheese. Rich, savory, and totally irresistible — these wings are pure comfort food.

Sweet Barbecue Wings

Sweet, smoky, and saucy enough to make you lick your fingers clean. These wings bring that backyard barbecue flavor straight to your plate.

Naked and Afraid Wings

Stripped down and sizzling hot from the fryer. No sauce, no frills, just golden-crispy wings in all their natural glory.

Mango Habanero Wings

Crispy wings tossed in a sweet mango glaze with a bold habanero heat. Sticky, spicy, and irresistible.

10" Build Your Own

Your pie, your way. Six slices topped just how you like it. Perfect for a solo meal.

12" Build Your Own

Eight slices built to your taste. Pick your favorites and make it yours.

14" Build Your Own

Our most popular size, fully customizable with your choice of toppings. A classic for friends or a family.

16" Build Your Own

Twelve oversized slices loaded with whatever combination you crave. Great for groups.

Deep Dish Build Your Own

Sixteen filling slices with twice the crust — hearty, thick, and exactly how you want it.

24" Build Your Own

The ultimate canvas for your creativity. 28 slices of fully custom pizza built to feed a crowd.

10" Supreme

The perfect size for a personal feast. Six slices fully loaded with meats, veggies, and gooey mozzarella.

12" Supreme

Big enough to share or keep all to yourself. Eight slices stacked with pepperoni, sausage, ham, veggies, and cheese.

14" Supreme

Our most popular size — ten hearty slices that satisfy a group of friends or the whole family.

16" Supreme

Twelve oversized slices, fully loaded and perfect for the table to share and then some.

DD Supreme

Thick, filling, and twice the crust — sixteen meaty slices for a hungry group.

24" Supreme

A massive 24-inch Supreme showstopper loaded to the brim. 28 slices to keep the whole crew happy.

10" Garden Party

Six colorful slices bursting with fresh veggies — a cheesy garden on your plate.

12" Garden Party

Eight vibrant slices topped with mushrooms, peppers, olives, and tomatoes. Light, fresh, and perfect for sharing.

14" Garden Party

Ten hearty slices layered with every garden favorite and gooey mozzarella. A veggie feast for family night.

16" Garden Party

Twelve oversized slices piled with fresh veggies and bubbling cheese. A colorful way to feed the crew.

DD Garden Party

Sixteen thick, filling slices topped edge to edge with garden-fresh flavors on a double crust.

24" Garden Party

The veggie lover's showpiece. A giant 24-inch pie with 28 slices of fresh, colorful toppings — perfect for a crowd.

10" Chicken & Garlic

Six creamy Alfredo–covered slices with chicken, garlic, mushrooms, and onions — your own personal Clucky conquest.

12" Chicken & Garlic

Eight golden slices slathered in Alfredo and layered with chicken and roasted garlic. Perfect for two garlic-lovers.

14" Chicken & Garlic

Ten hearty slices of creamy, cheesy, garlicky perfection. A slayer’s delight for sharing with friends or family.

16" Chicken & Garlic

Twelve oversized slices loaded with chicken, mushrooms, onions, and gooey cheese over Alfredo sauce. Built to banish hunger.

DD Chicken & Garlic

Thicker, richer, and twice the crust — sixteen slices smothered in Alfredo with toppings stacked high.

24" Chicken & Garlic

The garlic-packed hero of any gathering. 28 slices of creamy Alfredo chicken magic ready to slay the hunger away at the partay.

10" Spicy Hawaiian

Six fiery slices of ham, pineapple, and jalapeños — small size, big kick. Recommended for one brave soul.

12" Spicy Hawaiian

Eight sweet-and-spicy slices perfect for two adventurous taste buds.

14" Spicy Hawaiian

Ten bold slices of tropical heat — pineapple, ham, jalapeños, and buffalo drizzle.

16" Spicy Hawaiian

Twelve oversized slices bringing sweet, spicy, and zesty flavor for the group.

DD Spicy Hawaiian

Sixteen thick slices that dial up the heat with every bite.

24" Spicy Hawaiian

The volcano-sized pizza. A 24-inch beast with 28 slices of fiery flavor for more than a whole crew of explorers to enjoy!

10" Riverside

Six bold slices loaded with Riverside flavor — pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and cheese.

12" Riverside

Eight flavorful slices, perfect for two, stacked with pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms.

14" Riverside

Ten hearty slices of Riverside pride — simple, bold, and satisfying.

16" Riverside

Twelve oversized slices topped with plenty of pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms.

DD Riverside

Sixteen thick pieces with double the crust, loaded with Riverside’s classic trio.

24" Riverside

The Riverside legend, party-sized. A 24-inch pie with 28 slices of pure flavor.

10" Meat Lovers

Six meaty slices stacked with pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, and beef — carnivore heaven for one.

12" Meat Lovers

Eight hearty slices packed with every meat in the house. Perfect for splitting with a fellow meat lover.

14" Meat Lovers

Ten slices loaded with bold, savory flavor — meats piled high and smothered in cheese.

16" Meat Lovers

Twelve oversized slices of pure meaty indulgence. Enough to satisfy the hungriest table.

DD Meat Lovers

Sixteen thick, filling slices with double crust strength — built to hold up all that meat.

24" Meat Lovers

The meat mountain. A giant 24-inch pie cut into 28 slices of carnivore-approved glory.

10" BBQ Chicken Pizza

Your own BBQ masterpiece. Six saucy slices loaded with smoky chicken, sweet white onions, and mushrooms, all bubbling under golden mozzarella.

12" BBQ Chicken Pizza

A shareable BBQ fix. Eight slices brushed with tangy sauce, topped with chicken, onions, mushrooms, and plenty of cheese.

14" BBQ Chicken Pizza

The BBQ classic, family-style. Ten hearty slices stacked with smoky chicken, tender onions, earthy mushrooms, and melty mozzarella.

16" BBQ Chicken Pizza

Turn up the flavor with twelve oversized slices of saucy BBQ goodness — chicken, onions, mushrooms, and cheese in every bite.

DD BBQ Chicken Pizza

Extra thick and extra bold. Sixteen filling slices on double crust, smothered in BBQ sauce and topped with chicken, onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella.

24" BBQ Chicken Pizza

The BBQ blockbuster. A giant 24-inch pie cut into 28 saucy, smoky slices — guaranteed to feed the whole crew.

10" Hawaiian

Six tropical slices of ham and pineapple, cheesy and sweet — a mini island escape.

12" Hawaiian

Eight slices of classic Hawaiian flavor. Great for sharing or savoring all to yourself.

14" Hawaiian

Ten hearty slices stacked with sweet pineapple and smoky ham. A family favorite.

16" Hawaiian

Twelve oversized slices that bring tropical flavor to the table.

DD Hawaiian

Sixteen thick slices that make ham and pineapple extra hearty.

24" Hawaiian

The Hawaiian getaway built for a crowd. A 24-inch pie cut into 28 slices of sunshine.

Garden

Fresh, crisp, and colorful! Lettuce, tomato, black olives, and pepperoncini all tossed together with mozzarella for a garden-fresh crunch in every bite.

Chef

A meaty masterpiece! Roast beef and turkey team up over crisp lettuce with tomato, black olives, pepperoncini, and mozzarella. A salad hearty enough to be the main course.